Just like Hannibal from the A-Team, I love it when a plan comes together. I have been sitting on a Groupon (Groupon Site is here) for Chester’s and with fall having come it was Clambake time. So I was very pleased when on visiting Chester’s website I noticed that they were doing Clambakes on the weekends in October. Sounded like a good way to spend a Friday night, chowing down on some tasty bivalves.
Chester’s is easy enough to get to, located at 11 Chester Street, Painesville, Ohio 44077 just a stones throw from the Painesville exit of Route 2, the location is convenient, if nothing else. The outside is a fairly nondescript building, but there is a decent sized parking lot and a small patio on one side. 
Walking in I was quickly greeted and then seated at a high two top next to the windows and right at the transition between the bar area and the dining room. The decor is clean and comfortable, heavy on wood and earthtones, but looking very well kept and timeless. This is the kind of place you would think of as nice, but probably wouldn’t be able to remember anything specific. A long bar with a lowered ceiling presents a comfortable area to grab a drink and settle in.
Chester’s menu (go here to check it out) is a nice selection of American and Tavern classics, with an emphasis on fish and seafood, a good sign for me since that is my wheelhouse. Also included was the specials with several variations on the Clam Bake (Clams, Clams & Chicken & Clams & Steak). I settled on the Clams & Clams which included 2 dozen clams, chowder and sides. I also ordered the Shrimp Chester appetizer.
First up was a cup of the New England Clam Chowder. This was a very nice rendition of the classic recipe, thick, but not over loaded with cream, the mild soup was stocked with chunks of potatoes and plenty of tender fresh clams. Very satisfying and a good way to get my seafood taste buds going.
Next up was the Shrimp Chester ($10), good sized fresh shrimp smothered in a wonderful garlic sauce and cheese and ba
ked to perfection. Sided with garlic bread, this was a cannot miss treat. Simply presented, the aroma got me as soon as this was set in front of me. The shrimp were perfectly cooked, tender and firm and wonderfully complimented by the garlicky cheesy goodness, that managed to get even better as it cooled and set up. With the bread there to soak up the extra sauce, this was a very well thought out and executed dish.
Next up was the main course and the reason I made the trip East. The two dozen clams came out in the classic fiber bowl with melted butter and extra clam broth for dipping. Sides were the ear of corn and I substituted sweet potato fries for the regular sweet potato. 
Portions were large, with the clams generally coming in about half dollar sized and steamed in their shells. The clams were mild and tender, each a mouthful of the goodness of the sea perfectly complimented by the drawn butter. Out of the 2 dozen clams, I had 3 that didn’t open (and you should always leave these be), but I had more then enough to satisfy my hunger. The corn was sweet and fresh and the sweet potato waffle fries were crispy on the outside and sweet and delicious on the inside. At $26 for the Clams and Clams bake, not cheap, but considering the amount of food and the quality, I think they give you what you expect.
Service was good and friendly, although there seemed to be a bit of a lag on the time for food to come out of the kitchen, it might be that I was there early and they hadn’t hit there groove yet, but I would hope they would be more on top of things when most of the tables were empty.
Chester’s is a place worth checking out, especially if you are in the area. The food is good, well prepared and presented nicely. There is not a lot of flourish or trendiness here, but that can be a very good thing. The biggest thing working against Chester’s is location, if they were located a couple miles North in Fairport Harbor or Grand River I think that they would be more well known, but as it is this a great place to get some good solid food. Chester’s is trying to push their presence with some of the Groupon and radio and TV station offers, so if you look around you might be able to get a deal. Check them out.
Posts
